This book aims to be a definitive source of reference for both hibernate and its JPA implementation. The authors undertake an arduous task of explaining each and every detail both in hibernate and JPA parlance. The end result is a comprehensive tutorial/reference guide of both worlds in one well-written and easy-to-read book. Think about this, if your goal is to to learn only hibernate, you have it here, or if all you need is to learn the JPA specification, you got that here too. The most beneficial of all, if you wanted to learn both, compare and contrast them, and make an informed decision of the best approach for your next project, then you are still in the right place. Can this get any better? Keep reading.
With a whopping 850+ pages, this book has loads of information for a reader at any experience level. The entire subject area is broadly organized into 3 parts.
Part 1: Getting started with Hibernate and JPA
Part 2: Mapping concepts and strategies
Part 3: Conversational object processing
Part 1 introduces you to the object/relational paradigm mismatch - both structural and conceptual aspects. Then, we are taken through a tour of how to start a new hibernate project. The authors then lay-out the types of projects that will benefit from ORM and those that wont. Based on the conclusion that the projects with rich domain model will best benefit from ORM, we are then briefly introduced to the art of creating rich domain models using an example application (Caveat Emptor). This example application will be used throughout the rest of the book to explain various concepts and strategies.
Part 2 is largely about the most important concept of hibernate - mapping classes to tables. Starting with the simplest scenario, the authors discuss every possible use-case that may present itself in a data-driven application and provide a mapping solution for the same. One-to-One, One-to-Many, Many-to-One, Many-to-Many, Inheritance mapping, component mapping, mapping collections of components and many more are discussed in detail, along with recommendations on which one to use when. The authors also discuss the pitfalls when taking a bottom-up approach and its solutions. Every chapter explains the mapping meta-data in all 3 formats - hibernate XML, JPA XML and JPA annotations. Since JPA has some limitations, every possible limitation is pointed out and ways to get back to native hibernate to achieve the same effect is discussed.
Part 3 is a complete tutorial on the API for storing and retrieving objects. The authors start with the basics of how to persist, retrieve, query etc., and proceed by dedicating entire chapters for every advanced concept. Transactions & Concurrency, Implementing Conversations, Modifying objects efficiently, Retrieving objects using query and criteria api all receive their own chapters. Every chapter explains the API in both native hibernate as well as JPA parlance. Whenever a JPA limitation is encountered, the authors show the best fall-back strategy to native hibernate.
Towards the end, the authors briefly show us the art and science of writing layered applications with hibernate. As an added bonus, we also get a primer into JBoss Seam, which solves many problems related to writing layered applications using the now famous EJB 3.0 specification. Two appendices, one explaining the fundamentals of SQL and the other acting as a reference for mapping concepts are also very useful.
The authors are very ambitious in trying to cover all the features of both Hibernate 3.x and JPA specification. This is an arduous task and kudos for just aiming for that level of comprehensiveness. Praises aside, i am not very impressed with the ad-hoc approach taken to explain both these giants side-by-side. Some chapters clearly separate hibernate and JPA sections, whereas some chapters entangle them into a mess. I personally preferred the chapters that clearly separated these sections. That gives me the choice, as a reader, to select one or the other, and to focus on my choice. But for some reason, most chapters chose to discuss them in an entangled fashion leaving me more confused than i was before the start.
I was expecting at least a primer on Hibernate/Lucene integration, but the authors chose to safely eliminate the topic, probably because the feature is still in its infancy. Also, it was strange that there was no trace of spring framework anywhere in the book, knowing for a fact that spring has a lot to offer to any ORM implementation.
Though there is room for improvement, there is currently no match for this book in terms of the coverage offered. Explanations are lucid, examples are excellent, and the author's ability to foresee the next questions in the reader's mind and address them immediately is fabulous .
I highly recommend this book
- For those who are interested in learning hibernate 3.x and JPA specification
- For those who crave practical advices for real-world scenarios
- For those who wish to choose between native hibernate and JPA, based on facts, not just techno-babble
In case you are wondering what i chose, i chose native hibernate.
